All About Icon of the Seas: Review, Pros, Cons and Everything In Between

🎤 Episode Overview

We just got back from a week on Icon of the Seas with our crew of twelve — spanning ages 4 to 78, toddler to great-grandparent — over New Year’s. In this episode of Family Travel Unpacked, I share the comprehensive honest review: what worked beautifully for our multigenerational group, what the ship does better than any other, where it fell short, and the specific tips that will make your Icon sailing more enjoyable if you go.

This is a long one, but Icon is a big ship with a lot to cover.

🎧 Listen to This Episode

You can also listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you stream podcasts.

🛳️ Planning & Logistics in This Episode

The Ship’s Neighborhood Structure: How It Manages Crowds

Icon of the Seas carries 7,600+ passengers, which sounds terrifying until you understand how it’s designed. The ship is divided into distinct ‘neighborhoods’ — Central Park, Thrill Island, Surfside, Chill Island, etc. — each with its own vibe, pool situation, and programming. The effect is that you rarely feel like you’re on a ship with nearly 8,000 people; you feel like you’re in a moderately-sized resort zone.

For families with kids of different ages and interests, this structure is genuinely useful. Our toddler contingent lived in Surfside (the family-oriented neighborhood with the wading pools and interactive water features). The older kids gravitated toward Thrill Island. The grandparents found Chill Island and barely moved.

Connected Balcony Hack for Multigenerational Travel

If you’re traveling with a multi-generational group, book connecting or adjacent balcony cabins on the same deck — ideally with balconies that can be opened between each other. The Deck 8 aft location was excellent for our group: close to the main activity decks, great sightlines, and the interior-connecting cabin option let us move between rooms without going into the hallway. This setup made the trip exponentially easier for managing kids across family units.

Water Slides: The Reality Check

The Category 6 water slides are genuinely thrilling. They’re also extremely popular and lines can be long mid-day. Strategy: go first thing in the morning (8–9 AM) or after dinner (8 PM+). Wristbands are required and assigned by category. If water slides are your primary activity goal, be strategic about timing or you’ll spend half the day waiting.

Kids Club: The Weakest Part

Icon’s Adventure Ocean kids club programming is functional but was, in our honest assessment, the weakest part of the ship for families. The age groupings felt broad and the programming wasn’t as developed as we’d hoped. For comparison, Disney’s kids club programming is dramatically better. If kids club is a priority for your sailing, Icon is not the top choice; it’s more about the ship’s facilities than the organized programming.

Western Caribbean Ports

Our itinerary hit Costa Maya, Roatan, Cozumel, and CocoCay. Costa Maya and Roatan were both excellent — manageable port towns with good independent excursion options for families. Cozumel is a classic Caribbean port and hard to go wrong. CocoCay is Royal Caribbean’s private island, and it’s genuinely well-designed for families: good beaches, a lagoon with great snorkeling, and the Thrill Waterpark add-on option.

Dining Highlights and Tips

The Main Dining Room covers the basics reliably. For a stand-out experience, the Izumi Sushi lunch deal was an unexpected favorite — reasonably priced and excellent quality. The buffet (Windjammer) is exactly what you’d expect from a cruise ship buffet — fine, not exciting.

One critical mistake we made: the arcade. Set a per-child spending limit before you embark and stick to it. Without a cap, it becomes a money pit in a way that sneaks up on you.

Entertainment

Entertainment winners from our sailing: Lou’s Jazz n’ Blues, The Passing Zone (a juggling/comedy act that was legitimately excellent for the whole age range), and the AquaAction show on the pool deck. The main theater productions were solid but not spectacular.

Accessibility for Grandparents

Icon handles mobility reasonably well for a ship this size. The neighborhoods mean grandparents can stake out a comfortable spot and have the action come to them rather than needing to traverse the ship. The elevators are numerous enough that waits aren’t painful. That said, some areas — particularly around the pool decks — involve more walking than you’d expect.

🛳️ Common Questions About Icon of the Seas

Is Icon of the Seas worth the hype?

For families with a wide age range, yes. The neighborhood structure genuinely works, and there’s enough for everyone that the challenge of keeping different generations happy is solved almost by design. For couples or solo travelers, there are better ships; Icon is optimized for families.

Is 7,600 passengers too many?

Less than you’d think. The neighborhood system distributes the crowd effectively. That said, embarkation day and the water slides during peak hours will remind you of the passenger count.

What’s the one thing to know before sailing?

Set spending limits for the arcade before you board. The entertainment and activities are largely covered in the cruise fare; the arcade is not, and it’s positioned in a high-traffic area that kids walk through repeatedly.